Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLP vs Jayco Eagle 370FBTS
2026 Fifth Wheel comparison · side-by-side specs, verdict, and who each is best for.
Photo unavailable
Photo unavailableQuick verdict
Two Fifth Wheel rigs aimed at couples but at different luxury tiers. The Dutchmen Astoria 3173RLP is 36.7 ft, 10,375 lbs dry, 12,000 lb GVWR with 2,299 lb hitch weight. Rear-living couples layout sleeps 4 with 44 gal fresh, 78 gal grey, 39 gal black. No listed solar, four-season rating, residential fridge or outdoor kitchen. MSRP $76,456.
The Jayco Eagle 370FBTS is 40.67 ft, 12,195 lbs dry, 14,300 lb GVWR with 2,355 lb hitch. Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance. Sleeps 4. MSRP $84,893.
Directional verdict: pick the Dutchmen Astoria 3173RLP for $8,437 less in a shorter 36.7 ft footprint if you want a Fifth Wheel rear-living layout without paying for luxury content.
Side-by-side specs
| Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLP | Jayco Eagle 370FBTS | |
|---|---|---|
| MSRP | $76,456 | $84,893 |
| Length | 36'8" | 40'8" |
| Dry weight | 10,375 lbs | 12,195 lbs |
| GVWR | 12,000 lbs | 14,300 lbs |
| Sleeps | 4 | 4 |
| Slides | — | 1 |
| Fresh tank | 44 gal | 81 gal |
| Grey tank | 78 gal | 87 gal |
| Black tank | 39 gal | 87 gal |
| LP | — | 60 gal |
| Solar | — | 200W |
| Inverter | — | — |
| Generator | — | — |
| Bath | — | full |
| Bed | — | king |
| 4-season | No | Yes |
| Off-road | No | No |
| Outdoor kitchen | No | Yes |
| Washer/dryer | none | prep |
| Residential fridge | No | Yes |
Where Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLP wins
- $8,437 cheaper at $76,456 MSRP
- 3.97 ft shorter (36.7 vs 40.67 ft)
- 1,820 lbs lighter dry (10,375 vs 12,195 lbs)
- 56 lbs less hitch weight (2,299 vs 2,355 lbs)
- Rear-living layout for view-out-the-back camping
Where Jayco Eagle 370FBTS wins
- King bed (3173RLP bed unlisted)
- Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance.
- 200W solar plus residential fridge plus outdoor kitchen
- NuvoH20 water filtration plus GE appliances plus HELIX Cooling
- Washer/dryer prep plus 37 gal more fresh (81 vs 44 gal)
Pick the Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLP if…
Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance. The Dutchmen Astoria 3173RLP at 36.7 ft fits more campsites than the 40.67 ft Eagle 370FBTS and tows with less hitch weight.
Pick the Jayco Eagle 370FBTS if…
Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance. The Jayco Eagle 370FBTS at $84,893 packs flagship-tier features into a 40.67 ft package. Needs a 1-ton truck for the 14,300 lb GVWR. Skip it if your campsite max is 38 ft or you don't need premium content.
Frequently asked
What is NuvoH20 filtration?
A salt-free water softener and filtration system that reduces hard-water scale buildup in plumbing and appliances. Useful for full-time use where you'll see varied campground water quality.
Which fits more campsites?
The Astoria 3173RLP at 36.7 ft fits most modern destination sites (40+ ft). The Eagle 370FBTS at 40.67 ft is too long for many older parks and national forest sites; verify length limits.
Is the Eagle 370FBTS worth $8,437 more?
Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance. For fair-weather couples camping, the Astoria's price advantage is more compelling.