PW PIRKAWAKKA

Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLP vs Jayco Eagle 321RSTS

2026 Fifth Wheel comparison · side-by-side specs, verdict, and who each is best for.

Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLPPhoto unavailable

Dutchmen

Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLP

$76,456 · 36'8" · sleeps 4

Full Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLP details →
Jayco Eagle 321RSTSPhoto unavailable

Jayco

Eagle 321RSTS

$79,985 · 36'7" · sleeps 4

Full Jayco Eagle 321RSTS details →

Quick verdict

Two 36-ft luxury Fifth Wheel rear-living couples coaches separate by $3,529 of price. The Dutchmen Astoria 3173RLP is 36.7 ft, 10,375 lb dry, sleeps 4, $76,456, with no four-season, no solar, no outdoor kitchen, basic appliances. Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance.

Nearly identical length (within 1.5 inches) and matching 4-person sleep counts. The Dutchmen Astoria 3173RLP saves 770 lb of dry weight as the trade.

Verdict: pick the Jayco Eagle 321RSTS at $79,985 for the feature-loaded build. The Dutchmen Astoria 3173RLP at $76,456 only wins if 770 lb of tow-weight savings is critical to your tow vehicle math.

Side-by-side specs

Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLPJayco Eagle 321RSTS
MSRP$76,456$79,985
Length36'8"36'7"
Dry weight10,375 lbs11,145 lbs
GVWR12,000 lbs13,200 lbs
Sleeps44
Slides—1
Fresh tank44 gal81 gal
Grey tank78 gal87 gal
Black tank39 gal50 gal
LP—60 gal
Solar—200W
Inverter——
Generator——
Bath—full
Bed—king
4-seasonNoYes
Off-roadNoNo
Outdoor kitchenNoYes
Washer/dryernoneprep
Residential fridgeNoYes

Where Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLP wins

  • $3,529 cheaper at $76,456
  • 770 lb lighter dry (10,375 vs 11,145)
  • 0.12 ft more length at 36.7 ft
  • 29-lb heavier hitch supports trailer tracking
  • Rear-living layout for two-adult use

Where Jayco Eagle 321RSTS wins

  • Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance.
  • NuvoH20 water filtration system
  • GE appliances and theater seating
  • Outdoor kitchen plus 200W solar
  • Residential fridge and washer/dryer prep

Pick the Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 3173RLP if…

Couples who want a 36-ft rear-living fifth wheel at the lower entry price and the lightest tow weight in this comparison. The Dutchmen Astoria 3173RLP at $76,456 saves $3,529 plus 770 lb of curb weight, useful for marginal half-ton tow setups. Skip it if you want any of the comfort or technology features.

Pick the Jayco Eagle 321RSTS if…

Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance. The Jayco Eagle 321RSTS at $79,985 delivers the full premium feature stack for $3,529 more - cheaper than installing those features aftermarket.

Frequently asked

Which has the king bed?

Only the Jayco Eagle 321RSTS has a king bed. The Dutchmen Astoria 3173RLP uses a queen-class master.

Which is rated for cold weather?

Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance. The Dutchmen Astoria 3173RLP requires winterization.

Which has the NuvoH20 system?

Only the Jayco Eagle 321RSTS has NuvoH20 water filtration. The Dutchmen Astoria 3173RLP uses conventional water systems.