PW PIRKAWAKKA

Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 230ML vs Jayco Eagle HT 31QCD

2026 Fifth Wheel comparison · side-by-side specs, verdict, and who each is best for.

Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 230MLPhoto unavailable

Dutchmen

Astoria Fifth Wheel 230ML

$68,600 · 28'2" · sleeps 6

Full Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 230ML details →
Jayco Eagle HT 31QCDPhoto unavailable

Jayco

Eagle HT 31QCD

$66,750 · 36'6" · sleeps 7

Full Jayco Eagle HT 31QCD details →

Quick verdict

These two Fifth Wheel layouts split on size and configuration. The Dutchmen Astoria 230ML is 28.2 ft long, 7,514 lbs dry, 9,680 lb GVWR with 1,293 lb hitch weight. Sleeps 6, with 44 gal fresh, 78 gal grey, 39 gal black. No listed solar, four-season rating, residential fridge or outdoor kitchen. MSRP $68,600.

The Jayco Eagle HT 31QCD is 36.5 ft long, 9,835 lbs dry, 11,700 lb GVWR with 2,080 lb hitch. Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance. Sleeps 7. MSRP $66,750.

Directional verdict: pick the Jayco Eagle HT 31QCD for $1,850 less. The Astoria 230ML's only structural advantage is being 8.3 ft shorter and 2,321 lbs lighter dry for tight campsites and lighter tow vehicles.

Side-by-side specs

Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 230MLJayco Eagle HT 31QCD
MSRP$68,600$66,750
Length28'2"36'6"
Dry weight7,514 lbs9,835 lbs
GVWR9,680 lbs11,700 lbs
Sleeps67
Slides——
Fresh tank44 gal52 gal
Grey tank78 gal82 gal
Black tank39 gal45 gal
LP—60 gal
Solar—200W
Inverter——
Generator——
Bath—full
Bed—queen
4-seasonNoYes
Off-roadNoNo
Outdoor kitchenNoYes
Washer/dryernonenone
Residential fridgeNoYes

Where Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 230ML wins

  • 8.3 ft shorter (28.2 vs 36.5 ft) for tight campsites
  • 2,321 lbs lighter dry (7,514 vs 9,835 lbs)
  • 787 lbs less hitch weight (1,293 vs 2,080 lbs)
  • 301 lbs more cargo capacity (2,166 vs 1,865 lbs)
  • Catalog figures do not establish vehicle fit or towing suitability.

Where Jayco Eagle HT 31QCD wins

  • $1,850 cheaper at $66,750 MSRP
  • Sleeps 7 vs 6
  • 200W solar plus residential fridge plus outdoor kitchen
  • Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance.
  • 8 gal more fresh (52 vs 44 gal); 60 gal LP capacity

Pick the Dutchmen Astoria Fifth Wheel 230ML if…

Owners with smaller tow vehicles, tighter campsites or older travel-trailer parks with shorter spaces. The Dutchmen Astoria 230ML's 28.2 ft length, 7,514 lb dry weight and 1,293 lb hitch weight make it the easier-towing Fifth Wheel for half-ton owners running short on payload margin. Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance.

Pick the Jayco Eagle HT 31QCD if…

Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance. The Eagle HT 31QCD's MORryde suspension, Olympic mattress and 60 gal LP support extended-stay use. Catalog figures do not establish vehicle fit or towing suitability.

Frequently asked

Why is the Eagle HT 31QCD heavier but $1,850 cheaper?

Jayco's volume pricing on the Eagle HT line makes more length and content cheaper. The Astoria 230ML's price reflects Dutchmen's positioning rather than a feature gap; spec-for-spec, the Eagle delivers more for less.

Is the Astoria 230ML easier for a half-ton truck?

In this unverified catalog, towing suitability is not established, including any claimed advantage in matching a trailer to a tow vehicle. Dry weight is not loaded weight, and a vehicle class or 'half-ton towable' label is not fit approval. For each trailer under consideration, compare its actual loaded weight and loaded tongue weight (or pin weight for a fifth wheel) against the exact vehicle's manufacturer-specified tow, payload, axle, receiver/hitch and gross combined weight rating (GCWR) limits. Include occupants, cargo, options and hitch equipment in the vehicle's loaded weight and payload use. Follow the vehicle and trailer manuals and rating labels; seek qualified help if the required weights, limits or compatibility are unclear.

Which is better for cold weather?

Catalog flags do not independently verify winter performance. The Astoria 230ML has no four-season rating listed and no LP capacity in its spec sheet.